Mainely Seafood Market & Cafe

Lobster Rolls

Signature Maine-style lobster rolls with a quarter-pound of fresh lobster meat. Served hot with butter or cold with mayo on toasted split-top buns.

• Quarter-pound fresh lobster per roll
• Choice of hot or cold preparation
• Served with fries and coleslaw

Fresh Seafood Entrees

Daily selections of fresh clams, shrimp, ahi tuna, and other catches prepared to order. All dishes emphasize fresh ingredients and simple, quality preparation.

• Fresh clams and steamers
• Grilled and fried shrimp options
• Seared ahi tuna specialties

Seafood Market

Fresh seafood market offering daily catches and specialty items. Take home fresh ingredients or enjoy prepared foods on-site.

• Daily fresh catch selections
• Market-fresh ingredients
• Take-home seafood options

Appetizers & Sides

Complement your meal with fresh appetizers like lobster bisque and calamari, plus sides including hand-cut fries and onion rings.

• Creamy lobster bisque
• Fresh fried calamari
• Hand-cut fries and onion rings

“A very unassuming place with fresh food in a very casual atmosphere. This is a market and a cafe which great service. My husband had the clams which he loved. I had the lobster roll that came with a side of butter which was delicious. Perfect size…perfect taste. Definitely a great place for a quick meal…as long as you don’t mind sleeping like the food after!! Definitely worth it. We definitely recommend.”

“We were visiting friends in the area and they suggested to eat here. They have eaten there several times. The food was delicious! My husband had the clams & onion rings, he said the best he has ever had. I had the shrimp meal with fries & the coleslaw was good. The shrimp were amazing & the service was great & the food was served hot.”

“Mainely Seafood Café I wanted a Lobster Roll, so we had to stop by and see what this place is all about. It’s at the right end of Turtle Crossings shopping plaza on Burnt Store Road. This place was neat and clean and very well organized. It is a Café and Market everything inside is simple but fits the décor of a Seafood establishment. We got there around 12 noon and surprisingly we were the only people in the place. Our server Brianna came over to our table took our drink orders fast. They do serve alcohol and soft drinks. For starters we ordered the Creamy Lobster Bisque Soup, a Beer, and some Wine. For the main dish I ordered the Lobster roll Meal with has a ¼ pound of Lobster served on a split top bun with Butter, Fries and Cole Slaw for about 24.00. You can get it cold with Mayo or hot with Butter. I got an alternate side of Onion Rings instead of Fries for 3.00 extra. My wife just ordered the same thing but with the Fries. Our soup came out first and it was very good. Our Lobster Rolls came out shortly afterwards. The looked amazing and they were. The roll was toasted and overflowing with Lobster the butter to pour or dip into was a nice addition. The Onion Ring were done perfect as was the Fries. Even the Cole Slaw was pretty good. Brianna was on the ball asking us if everything was all right and checking on us, but I do wish she was a little more cordial. This is one of them so called hidden little gems and I for one can’t wait to go back. Make sure you put this on your to do list. I must give this place a 5 out of 5 stars. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Follow Me For Fun & Reviews Gulf Coast Terry”

“I love to eat here. I just love the auhi tuna. It is my favorite. The price is perfect, the taste amusing and only a few calories. Perfect, perfect, perfect. The service is truly the best. We were there between 1:00 to 1:30 pm on Monday February 16, 2026. Please pass on to the young lady she was wonderful and thank you for everything. No photos. Sorry. I was too focused on eating. It is so good.”

Burnt Store Marina & Golf (Punta Gorda Isles Section 22)

⭐ 4.2 (39) · 1.6 miles

5000 Burnt Store Road North, Punta Gorda